Difference between revisions of "Testimonials"
| Line 44: | Line 44: | ||
In order to make an opinion base on the experience of others, consideration must be made about the author of testimonials. Individuals have certain biases that may affect their opinion on the service or product they received. What may be negative to one individual may not represent the feelings of the prospective consumer. The same is argued for a positive review may not indicate the same pleasures. | In order to make an opinion base on the experience of others, consideration must be made about the author of testimonials. Individuals have certain biases that may affect their opinion on the service or product they received. What may be negative to one individual may not represent the feelings of the prospective consumer. The same is argued for a positive review may not indicate the same pleasures. | ||
| − | Authors may also have various forms of motives. An author may have had some influence by the service or product in question to encourage a positive review. Reviews can also be by the business staged as an unaffiliated individual. There are also motivations that incur negative testimonies. The author may have a gripe to something or someone that is affiliated with the service or product but doesn't concern the good itself (ie.a negative relationship with the owner). Another motivation can be from an individual from the same market in order to reduce the ratings of competing businesses. | + | Authors may also have various forms of motives. An author may have had some influence by the service or product in question to encourage a positive review. Reviews can also be by the business staged as an unaffiliated individual. |
| + | |||
| + | There are also motivations that incur negative testimonies. The author may have a gripe to something or someone that is affiliated with the service or product but doesn't concern the good itself (ie.a negative relationship with the owner). Another motivation can be from an individual from the same market in order to reduce the ratings of competing businesses. | ||
==Ethics== | ==Ethics== | ||
Revision as of 19:06, 15 March 2019
A testimony is a formal or informal statement that reflects the characteristics of an individual, organization, or service. The term testimony is used often by a business when they themselves gather and manage testimonies regarding their services. Testimonials owned and managed by a third party is a type of testimony known as a review.
Testimonials have shaped consumerism by subconsciously influencing our decision making. Consumers are unaware of the legitimacy of many of the testimonies, yet continue to rely on them for everyday purchases. This article will discuss how testimonies grew in consumerism interest, questions the reliability, and analyzes the ethics of testimony.
Contents
History
Before the Internet
Testimonials were only exchanged between relatives, friends, and co-workers before the introduction of the internet. Recommendations were given and opinions were offered. Services given by new businesses were a higher risk to the consumer. Consumers tend to go with familiarity rather than the unknown. Only when testimonials from peers framed a service from a business or a product as below par, is when new business earned the opportunity to differentiate and provide their services.
There was a lot of risk for new businesses as any misstep could result in the consumer talking ill about their service or product. Yet, exceeding expectations creates the opportunity for recommendations and improved business in the consumers' network.
Testimonials did not impact consumers outside of previous customers’ networks. New consumers were persuaded solely on marketing and it was up to the marketer to meet expectations of that service or product.
The Age of the Internet
Online testimonials and reviews replaced the traditional method of word-of-mouth indication of quality and have become the main form of forming a reputation[3].
Centralization
The internet has allowed for testimonies to expand beyond individuals' network of peers to encompass every consumer interested or experienced with the service or product in question. Websites allow for reviews to be congregated in one location so that consumers can have a better understanding of a new product or service.
Ratings
Ratings, often denoted by stars, provide a numerical value attributed to a service or product that allows consumers to compare between similar service or products. Ratings provide a condensed representation of the opinions within testimonials. [2]Ratings become an indicator of the content within all the testimonials without the need of reading through each testimony but still providing equal weight to reviews that aren't read by a prospective consumer.
Reliability
Polarized Distribution
Consideration must be made on the benefits one receives for writing a testimony. Testimonies (more specifically reviews) consist of a very polarized opinion based. Inspecting the marks given for ratings, it’s evident that the majority consists of either the lowest (for example one star) or the highest mark (five stars). Testimonies are driven between the idea that a service or product is good or bad.
The personal benefit a reviewer receives from writing a positive is none. It may satisfy a feeling of beholdmanship toward the business only if the consumer feels their services exceeded the monetary value that consumer paid. Beyond that, a positive review only benefits the reader.
The benefit a consumer receives from writing a negative review of a service or product is that they play the role of damaging the image of the business. It satisfies the feeling of vengefulness when they felt they were wronged. [1]Humans feel the pain of a loss (in these cases of monetary value or time) and will act on it more than if they were to gain from the situation, known as Loss Aversion.
Filterization
Filtering is the process of selecting testimonies to be displayed in an ordered list. The reader will read the reviews present to them from the filtering process and read only one or two reviews before establishing an opinion on the service or product. The dilemma arises when considering how to represent all the reviews of a given service or product within the few reviews the reader will actually read.
Weight is the differentiator of worth between one testimony to another. It is an important aspect when considering the order of how testimonials will be filtered and ultimately deciding the first and second written testimonies to be displayed before a consumer.
Earning Positive Testimonies
Businesses use different strategies in order to overcome the lackluster need for consumers to write positive testimonies.
- Providing incentives
- Paying for testimonies
- Writing positive Testimonies for one in return
- Asking directly to the consumer
These strategies aim to invoke the psychological response of reciprocity. It encourages the behavior of returning a favor the business went out of its way to do for the consumer. In this case, that action will be a positive testimony that will aid the growth of the business.
Author Credentials
In order to make an opinion base on the experience of others, consideration must be made about the author of testimonials. Individuals have certain biases that may affect their opinion on the service or product they received. What may be negative to one individual may not represent the feelings of the prospective consumer. The same is argued for a positive review may not indicate the same pleasures.
Authors may also have various forms of motives. An author may have had some influence by the service or product in question to encourage a positive review. Reviews can also be by the business staged as an unaffiliated individual.
There are also motivations that incur negative testimonies. The author may have a gripe to something or someone that is affiliated with the service or product but doesn't concern the good itself (ie.a negative relationship with the owner). Another motivation can be from an individual from the same market in order to reduce the ratings of competing businesses.
Ethics
Effects on Consumers
Effects on Organizations and Individual's Services
Accuracy
Desired Representation
Perceieved Representation
Objective Representation
References
- [2]Floridi, Luciano. The 4th Revolution: How the Infosphere Is Reshaping Human Reality. Oxford University Press, 2016
- [3]Luca, Michael, Reviews, Reputation, and Revenue: The Case of Yelp.Com (March 15, 2016). Harvard Business School NOM Unit Working Paper No. 12-016. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1928601 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1928601
- [1]The Quarterly Journal of Economics, Volume 106, Issue 4, 1 November 1991, Pages 1039–1061, https://doi.org/10.2307/2937956
